This is an unofficial snapshot of the ISO/IEC JTC1 SC22 WG21 Core Issues List revision 115e. See http://www.open-std.org/jtc1/sc22/wg21/ for the official list.

2024-11-11

9. Clarification of access to base class members

[Moved to DR at 4/01 meeting.]

11.8.3 [class.access.base] paragraph 4 says:

A base class is said to be accessible if an invented public member of the base class is accessible. If a base class is accessible, one can implicitly convert a pointer to a derived class to a pointer to that base class.

    class D;

    class B
    {
     protected:
       int b1;

       friend void foo( D* pd );
    };

    class D : protected B { };

    void foo( D* pd )
    {
       if ( pd->b1 > 0 ); // Is 'b1' accessible?
    }

1st interpretation:

A public member of B is accessible within foo (since foo is a friend), therefore foo can refer to b1 and convert a D* to a B*.

2nd interpretation:

B is a protected base class of D, and a public member of B is a protected member of D and can only be accessed within members of D and friends of D. Therefore foo cannot refer to b1 and cannot convert a D* to a B*.

(See J16/99-0042 = WG21 N1218.)

Proposed Resolution (04/01):

1. Add preceding 11.8.3 [class.access.base] paragraph 4:

   A base class B of N is accessible at R, if

   • an invented public member of B would be a public member of N, or
   • R occurs in a member or friend of class N, and an invented public member of B would be a private or protected member of N, or
   • R occurs in a member or friend of a class P derived from N, and an invented public member of B would be a private or protected member of P, or
   • there exists a class S such that B is a base class of S accessible at R and S is a base class of N accessible at R. [Example:

         class B {
         public:
             int m;
         };
     
         class S: private B {
             friend class N;
         };
     
         class N: private S {
             void f() {
     	    B* p = this;  // OK because class S satisfies the
     			// fourth condition above: B is a base
     			// class of N accessible in f() because
     			// B is an accessible base class of S
     			// and S is an accessible base class of N.
             }
         };
     

     —end example]

2. Delete the first sentence of 11.8.3 [class.access.base] paragraph 4:

   A base class is said to be accessible if an invented public member of the base class is accessible.

3. Replace the last sentence ("A member m is accessible...") by the following:

   A member m is accessible at the point R when named in class N if

   • m as a member of N is public, or
   • m as a member of N is private, and R occurs in a member or friend of class N, or
   • m as a member of N is protected, and R occurs in a member or friend of class N, or in a member or friend of a class P derived from N, where m as a member of P is private or protected, or
   • there exists a base class B of N that is accessible at R, and m is accessible at R when named in class B. [Example:...

The resolution for issue 207 modifies this wording slightly.